Sign in

Courtesy navigation

Five reasons you shouldn’t design your own logo

Comments (6)

Five reasons you shouldn’t design your own logo

February 18, 2010 by Fiona Humberstone

I feel very qualified to write this post at the moment. As the owner of a brand and marketing agency, I work with a lot of small business owners who are missing opportunities because their logo (and brand image as a whole) isn’t sending out the right signals.

And as someone who has just been client, creative director and designer (along with my other fabulous designers in the studio) for her own business, I can see things from the other side, too.

The fact is you really shouldn’t design your own logo. Here’s why.

1 You need outside perspective. Our clients tell us one of the most valuable things we bring to the table, aside from design, is the perspective we help them gain on their business. Working with a branding agency on your corporate identity forces you to think about the way your business is structured and who your most profitable clients really are. Working with someone who is not as close to your business provides a different – and important – perspective.

2 It’ll cost more than you think. You think design agencies get their design for free? Think again. I’ve spent thousands of pounds on developing the identity for Flourish, my new branding, graphic design and marketing services business. The staff cost and the opportunity cost of both my designers and I working on our own stuff rather than billable client work has been significant. And if you’re not a designer I recommend you focus on what you do best and let us get on with what we do best. More profitable all round – and the end result will be better.

3 Unless you’re a graphic designer, you’re unlikely choose the right fonts or colours. I’ve studied typography, colour psychology and logo design for years, as have my graphic designers. We understand how to evoke an emotion through a colour or a font.

4 You won’t add the creative flair your business deserves. Great logos have wow factor. Usually, they’re simple, but clever. And I don’t mean a Photoshop drop shadow (sooo nineties!) or a web 2.0 glassy reflection (oh so naughties!). I’m talking about a clever icon or creative treatment that will get your clients taking you seriously.

5 You’re too close to it. Being so involved in the design process makes it incredibly difficult to make objective decisions. In the end, the only way we broke through our creative block was for me to completely disassociate myself from the design and act as creative director only.

I see now why other design agencies commission someone else to design their logos. In the end, we managed to crack it ourselves and I have to say, I’m delighted with the end result. But if you’re not a graphic designer I urge you to invest in a professionally designed brand identity. It’ll be one of the best decisions you ever make.

Fiona Humberstone, Flourish design & marketing

startupdonutbannerbutton728x90

Bookmark and Share

Comments

Stefan Boyle's picture

Good comments on this... we see this all the time and carefully advise clients that professional presentation of their brand and image across every touchpoint of their business has just as much positive impact as a poor and unprofessional look has a negative impact! Often it is when the owner has created a logo or identity themselves and is proud of it, even if they may have little or no graphic design skills! Being tactful and managing the process to proving how it does not always mean huge expenditure to do it well!
here is an amusing clip which people in the graphic arts industry may find amusing!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x2h2pESo6HM

Brian Copeland's picture

Great blog Fiona! I can't stress point 3 enough. There's a reason people get degree's in design, because it's not easy and there is a heck of a lot to learn. I wouldn't, for example, take on my companies tax return, I'll employ someone qualified to do it. The same applies to design.

Nicky Parker's picture

As I am going through the agonies of deciding on a new website design at the moment, I'm definitely with you on this, Fiona.

It is so hard to step outside and look in to identify what is right for your own brand. And yet, I find it so easy to help my clients!

Ho, hum - back to looking at designs!

Five reasons you shouldn’t design your own logo « Start Up D's picture

[...] Five reasons you shouldn’t design your own logo « Start Up Donut blog 18/02/2010 http://startupdonutblog.co.uk/2010/02/18/five-reasons-you-shouldn%E2%80%... [...]

Fiona Humberstone's picture

It's a tricky one. I see what you're saying, but I'm not sure that it would be very supportive.

The idea behind this post was to highlight some of the challenges when it comes to designing your own logo. I'd hate to be the one to embarrass or belittle any business by featuring their logo in that way.

Jay Williams's picture

This is one of those posts which could have attracted global pick-up if there had been real examples of terrible logos featured. Just sayin. :0)

Add a comment

Not registered? We'll create a new account for you when you add your comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <p>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Not registered? We'll create a new account for you when you add your comment.
Account information
Your name on the Donut websites
Personal information
Your first and last name, please
We'll send your registration details here
Just the first part - eg SW17
Not in the UK? You can still leave comments:
I would like to receive the My Donut e-newsletter
Type the characters you see in this picture. (verify using audio)
Anti-spam check - enter the characters you see

When you click 'Register' to create a new account, you accept our terms of service and privacy policy