My company BCSG recently conducted some research to understand the attitudes smaller companies have towards hiring apprentices. We thought the results might be interesting in light of the government’s appointment of entrepreneur Jason Holt to review the success of UK apprenticeship schemes.
Most businesses have never had an apprentice
I was surprised to uncover that 78% of the small business owners we surveyed have never hired apprentices to join their workforce. They don’t have any plans to start, either. When asked what was stopping them, 44% said the associated training costs were too high and 30% said the red tape was too complex.
This perhaps explains why the government has recently introduced a flurry of new measures to encourage small businesses to hire and train apprentices:
I hope these measures help to boost apprentice recruitment, because although hiring apprentices may seem an expensive and labour intensive process, these aspiring business stars can make valuable contributions to the small business market:
Has your firm had any experience of employing apprentices? Has the red tape put you off? Leave a comment and let us know.
John Davis is managing director of Business Centric Services Group.
See also: http://www.lawdonut.co.uk/news/law/firms-must-take-on-apprentices-for-minimum-of-12-months
Company manuals and guidelines are not on the agenda when you’re starting a business – because usually it’s just you who works for the business.
However, once you start employing people it’s wise to set some “ground rules”. For example, a customer service guide will help with training new staff, providing them with a reference point for any issues they encounter in their early days on the job.
Here are a few simple tips on creating an effective customer service guide. I have focused on an online business, but it’s similar for an offline operation.
Though it’s your business and you know the standards and quality you expect, new employees may not. It won’t be long until your customer service team is the main contact point for your customers and they need to know how your business operates and what it promises. Otherwise they can’t adequately answer people’s queries.
The key points to cover are:
It often helps to create a short list of, say, five key points, ideas or practices that you feel are essential to your team. This could include things such as politeness and tone of voice. At my company, we have crucial targets, such as responding to all email enquires within 24 hours.
Starting a new job is overwhelming, so make sure you clearly explain the tasks relevant to the role you want that employee to perform.
If you have a sales team, as well as product knowledge, you’ll need details such as how to handle different payments, any limitations of the system (eg can’t accept American Express) or how account and new customers are dealt with.
For roles with more of a focus on service and support, product familiarity is also vital but in-depth knowledge of the sales process may not be necessary (though the ability to do a basic job can help cover staff absences or busy periods). Focus more on relevant factors such as knowledge of your suppliers or product training and troubleshooting.
For any piece of hardware and software, it’s essential that anyone working for your business understands its purpose and how to use it properly from both safety and efficiency viewpoints.
This doesn’t mean you need to copy out every user manual available, but some bullet points with tips can make the employee feel more comfortable and get them up to speed quickly.
Taking screenshots can often save time and effort when trying to describe a series of on-screen tasks. They are great, not only to complement instructions, but also to serve as verification that the correct stages have been followed.
It’s inevitable, your new customer service employee will need to be able to turn to someone with more experience or authority for help. This makes a quick-fire contact list of all employees (and their jobs) essential, and helps get problems resolved faster by streamlining issues that arise. Plus, you’d be amazed by the added confidence an employee can get from just knowing there is someone to turn to.
This area could also cover where to refer customers who’re looking for services you don’t provide. Draw up a shortlist of companies that don’t impinge on your market but are in a related niche. This can not only encourage customers to see you as being helpful, but also build relationships with those businesses. If you’re sending business to them they’ll be much more likely to send it back to you.
If you can distil some of the more essential information onto a single page that your team can pin up for quick reference, you’ll save time.
This can be anything from a flow chart for taking a payment by cheque to how to handle ‘difficult to scan’ barcodes (I’m looking at you and your eggs, Mr Cadbury). In non-retail situations this can be how to document an issue properly, or the correct series of questions to ask when troubleshooting a problem.
If it’s good, employees will refer to your manual and follow it, which is great, as long as the guidance is correct. It’s definitely worth re-evaluating this document periodically, as well as updating sections when new business practices, equipment or services become available.
I hope these tips help you streamline your processes and your new recruits are still smiling after settling-in! Have you got any tips that you’ve found really helped you to integrate a new team member?
At the end of last year we supported National Freelancers Day by running our very own survey.
We now have the results and we’ve created a rather awesome infographic called ‘A peep into freelancing’. You can read more on our recent blog piece here.
The infographic covers the how, what, who and where and when of freelancing and gives valuable insight into the pros and cons of starting up on your own.
Infographic by PolicyBee insurance
On the face of it, employing family members can be a good idea. You know them well, so all of the issues of trust and reliance on a stranger should be eliminated.
However, the existence of the family relationship does not bypass any employment laws or any issues relating to tax. Knowing your duties in this area is essential to not falling foul of the law and incurring fines or penalties.
Regardless of your business structure (sole trader or limited company) you can employ your partner or spouse in your business.
The general rule is that your partner or spouse should be paid for the effort and hours worked in your business. You must pay your partner or spouse at least the national minimum wage (you can’t get away with paying less).
Where the amount earned exceeds the “lower earning limit” (currently £102 a week, £442 a month or £5,304 a year) you must register as an employer with HM Revenue Customs (HMRC), complete the required PAYE records and file annual returns.
So, just like employing anyone else, you must comply with the tax laws.
Directors of limited companies who hold office and do not have a contract of employment are outside of the scope of the national minimum wage (see the Directgov website for further information)
This means that a director can be paid an amount that does not incur tax or national insurance.
Subject to employment laws, you can employ your children in the business. Again you must pay them the relevant national minimum wage for the hours they work.
It may also mean that because of the payments made to your children you must register with HMRC as an employer. Be sure to check or else you could incur fines and penalties.
If you employ a student at any time other than their normal holidays, you operate PAYE as normal. However, if you have children at college or university and you employ them solely during the summer, winter or Easter holidays, you may be able to apply special rules to their pay which can make the administration simpler and negate the need for you to register as an employer with HMRC.
If you meet this criteria, you may be able to pay the student without deducting tax, although in most cases you will still have to deduct and account for national insurance. Full details can be found on the HMRC website.
Employing anyone is complicated and a minefield of rules and regulation. To ensure that you do follow the rules on this it is always best to seek specific advice from your accountant who will know and understand your circumstances and can make sure that you adhere to the tax laws and your solicitor for employment law issues.
Using 20 years’ experience spent working at some of the UK’s leading businesses, award-winning chartered accountant Elaine Clark is the founder and managing director of www.cheapaccounting.co.uk, an online accounting service aimed at small businesses with big ambitions.
See our Tax Donut for more detailed information on UK tax
Today is National Freelancers Day and according to event organisers PCG (“the Voice of Freelancing”) it’s “a day to celebrate the value of independent workers to the UK economy.” And what value my fellow freelances and I (about 1.4m souls and counting) contribute to UK GDP (some £82bn according to PCG).
A campaign that aims “to raise the profile of freelancing in the UK across all audiences”, this is the third National Freelancers Day. Launched in 2009 with a series of UK-wide events, last year Prime Minister David Cameron’s voiced his support, while a host of events are planned for this year.
Freelances (the grammatically correct form) go by many other names, of course, such as “freelancer” (frequently used but grammatically incorrect), “independent worker", “contractor”, “consultant” – even “interim”, “portfolio worker” and “own account worker”. Crucially, they are self-employed or operate their own limited companies, so they run their own businesses, as well as helping others.
The term “freelance” (“free-lance” or “free-lancer”) isn’t new. In fact, it was first coined to refer to mercenary soldiers in Medieval Europe (users of modern day high fee-charging freelances can make up their own jokes).
In the past ten years the number of freelances in the UK has grown significantly. In 1998 there were some 1.25m; by 2008 this figure had increased by 14 percent to 1.4m. Of these, 62 per cent were male and 38 per cent female (Source: PCG). It is likely that there are now comfortably more than 1.5m freelances in the UK.
Apparently, freelancing is much less common in many other parts of Europe, but there’s little doubt that its popularity in the UK continues to increase. Many of those who have lost their jobs in recent years have turned to freelancing as either their best or only option. Many more businesses (including small firms) now rely heavily on freelances, who are viewed as the more flexible (and often more cost-efficient) solution to staffing needs.
So why use freelances? Well, it enables you to buy in the extra help you need as and when you need it, often that involves specialist knowledge you don’t possess in-house. And if the freelance’s performance falls short of your expectations, you don’t hire them again. You don’t have to pay them holiday pay or sick pay and they usually look after their own tax affairs. So freelances can boost your productivity, efficiency and profitability. But businesses be advised: working with freelances and contract workers brings with it legal responsibilities (including compliance with health and safety and National Minimum Wage regulations).
Many experts predict that the current growth in freelance activity will continue and in the near future this is how many more people in the UK will work, either full time or part time. As well as being good for UK business, the freelance life (which can be demanding, harsh and unpredictable at the best of times, believe me) at least offers the possibility of greater flexibility and control over our lives – personal and professional.
According to PCG: “The competitive advantage afforded the UK by its highly skilled, highly mobile and highly flexible freelance workforce must be nurtured and protected.” I’m sure politicians, business-owners and freelances throughout the land would agree.
Want to find out more about becoming a freelance? Download the Guide To Successful Freelancing
This is my third blog in a handful of months that is essentially about people issues in a start-up, but I make no apology for that. I will, however, admit that a few years ago, before I had actually started a business, I was a sceptic on this subject. But that was then, this is now.
If you are to be successful in a start-up, you need some self-confidence. If you don’t think you’ve got it, you won’t succeed. This is however, different from being like an X Factor contestant who believes he or she has a world-beating singing voice but sounds like an animal in pain. To be successful, you also have to be realistic and understand the balance of risks you are taking. Understanding your strengths – and playing to them – is part of that equation.
But how do you understand your strengths? Here I must recommend the book Strengthsfinder 2.0 by Tom Rath published by Gallup. I also suggest you take the online test that comes free with it. In my 30 years in businesses large and small, I’ve come across numerous tests, but this one is the best of all.
For a couple of my strengths, it says I should partner with someone who has particular complementary strengths. My first business partner had these strengths and our company, Actinic, reached the FTSE 350 within four years of starting out. My latest business partner also has these strengths, so hopefully watch this space.
The abilities of the founders are by far the most important factor in a start-up situation. Get these right and you’re well on your way to success. Enjoy the ride.
Jack Ford of the Sage UK Small Business Team
Sage runs UK-wide training courses to ensure our customers maximize the benefits from their software. Increasing your employees’ skills through training can benefit their professional them and your business.
Too many businesses see training as something they can cut back on to save money. A recent survey by the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development suggested smaller firms valued learning and development less highly than larger businesses.
You may be reluctant to spend money on something you perceive to be a luxury, especially in these tough economic times, but research by the UK Commission for Employment and Skills shows that in the last recession businesses that invested in their people’s skills were two-and-a-half times more likely to survive.
Training can bring about an increase in productivity, profits, motivation, loyalty and greater customer satisfaction. “It makes employees feel they’re more valued and they’re more likely to engage with their work as a result,” says HR advisor Ann Haydock. “They’re more likely to stay with your business, too – saving you time and money on recruitment.”
There are no legal requirements to train, but certain regulations encourage companies to foster a training environment. John McGurk, CIPD advisor for learning and talent, says: “The regulations on allowing time-off for training are like the flexible working regulations; a light-touch ‘nudge’ aimed at helping people to increase their training and development. We see it as a sensible step in encouraging individual employees to play their part in developing their own skills and talents within the competitive workplace.”
Jack Ford is part of the Small Business Team at Sage UK, Start Up Donut sponsor and provider of payroll and online accounting software to small businesses.
My recent column in the Financial Times about mentoring generated many responses from people wanting to learn more about how they can pass their knowledge onto the next generation of entrepreneurs. This is very encouraging; the single most important factor in increasing an entrepreneur’s chances of success is regular access to good mentors.
From the mentor’s point of view it is also a very rewarding process, but should only be embarked on for the right reasons. Mentoring should be provided for free; otherwise commercial considerations might intrude on the process.
Providing free mentoring also focuses your mind on whether you can really afford the time to offer this valuable service. You should already be financially secure or your business and customers doing well enough on their own, so you can provide mentoring without detriment to yourself or connections.
Last week I met with a perfect candidate for mentoring, a 60-year-old industry veteran with a successful consultancy. To explain how I run my one-hour mentoring sessions, I asked him to go through the same preparation I require from my mentees, to complete a simple psychometric profile and provide a one-page summary of where they are and where they want to get to.
I have been a keen advocate of psychometric tests ever since I met Sir Philip Trousdell, a former commandant at Sandhurst who has also run the NATO Operation in Bosnia and the British operation in Northern Ireland. He explained that the British Army had been using psychometric since the 1940s, and considered them a vital first step in selecting potential leaders.
After studying a number of different psychometric tests, I concluded that they generally map onto each other, providing similar conclusions about peoples’ aptitudes for certain tasks.
Some are quite deep and intense, measuring how you interact with other people and behave under stress, but for a first meeting with an entrepreneur, my personal preference is for a profiling system called Wealth Dynamics.
I have used this as a mentoring tool for several hundred people in the past five years, and find it highly effective at providing a basic overview of people’s potential strengths and weaknesses.
This test was developed by Roger Hamilton and is available on-line for $100. It explains that there are eight different ways to be a successful entrepreneur and gives examples of highly successful people whose particular path to success you can follow, depending on your own personal profile.
For my aspiring mentor, his profile showed that he was strong in three areas: as a “creator” coming up with new business ideas, a “mechanic” working out exactly how to deliver these new products and services, and as a “star”, using his personal charm to persuade people to ultimately buy them. He would be less motivated to work on the company finances, negotiate complex deals or concentrate on delivering the same thing every day.
This commendable versatility also has its negative side. His creativity might result in overloading the mentee with too many new ideas, his desire to deliver may turn into excessive interference and his natural radiance might incline him to overshadow his protégée.
Understanding the potentially negative side of one’s own character is vital for being an effective mentor. My own “star” profile often tempts me to respond to any perceived slight or poor customer service with the sentence “don’t you know who I am?”
I now realise that deploying this tactic always backfires sooner or later. There are much better ways of reaching a desired outcome, rather than letting one’s ego take over. Once I realised this, my own effectiveness as a mentor was significantly enhanced.
The Wealth Dynamics profile test can be found at www.wdprofiletest.com
Originally published in The Financial Times. Copyright ©Mike Southon 2011. All Rights Reserved. Not to be reproduced without permission in writing. Mike Southon is the co-author of The Beermat Entrepreneur and a business speaker.
“Buying an existing business can be less risky than creating one from scratch. If the business has customers, it has income. Risk is also easier to assess because you can calculate costs, turnover and profit – and thereby predict cashflow”
Emilie Corbille of www.daltonsbusiness.com
“If you want to form a new company, you must send Companies House your registration fee plus a memorandum of association, articles of association and a completed IN01 form, which details the company’s registered office and the names and addresses of its directors (and company secretary, if applicable)”
Andrew Millet of Wisteria Formations
“By putting away some money from your earnings each month – say, 25 per cent of your gross earnings – you should have more than enough money in the bank to take care of your tax bills”
James R McBrearty of www.taxhelp.uk.com
“Even if you believe you have an excellent idea for a business, you mustn’t allow yourself to get fooled into a false sense of optimism. Test it thoroughly by doing some basic market research. Only then can you move forward on any sound basis”
Start-up author Kevin Duncan
“You should minimise your start-up costs because then you’ll stand a better chance of surviving that crucial first year. Also, it’s a good discipline to get into from day one. In business, you must keep your costs as low as possible – and avoid buying things you don’t need”
Martin Dunne of Sayers Butterworth chartered accountants
“The old saying ‘turnover is vanity, profit sanity and cash reality’ remains true. Businesses go bust in the long term through lack of profit, but in the short term, they fail because they don’t have enough cash to pay their bills on demand. Cashflow is the lifeblood of any business”
Chartered Accountant Howard S Hackney
“Having a written contract clearly sets out the roles and responsibilities of both parties, which is helpful when it comes to monitoring the relationship’s success. It can also act as proof if a supplier’s performance falls short”
Marie Kell of Andrew Jackson solicitors
“The onus is on the business to ensure staff comply with legislation. An act of omission by an employee is likely to have consequences for the business. In some circumstances, directors may even be personally liable. The consequences can be drastic”
Kevin Turnbull of Muckle LLP Solicitors
“Editorial is regarded as more believable than an advert. I’ve read that it’s 50 per cent easier to sell to someone who has read positive things about your business, products or services. And such publicity is usually no cost or low cost. Even if you have to pay someone to do your PR, gaining one piece of coverage per month can be much cheaper than advertising”
Jane Lee of IT PR specialist Dexterity
“It’s low cost and therefore less risky, because there aren’t any expensive premises overheads. You can also claim for a percentage of your domestic bills, for lighting, heating, telephone calls, etc. A home office means no commute, so you save money and time, too”
Emma Jones of Enterprise Nation
The opportunity to be your own boss and make a living out of something you love doing is a dream come true, right?
Well, yes, of course it is. But it also involves masses of hard work, absolute commitment and a fair bit of paperwork. Being organised enough to make sure you’ve covered everything is a full-time job in itself.
The answer may be to take on more staff, but that means a change in dynamic. You’re very suddenly the one in charge. The buck stops with you and you’re the one tasked with covering all the bases – and that takes some getting used to.
However, like any person charged with running a business, you take your responsibilities seriously. You want to make work fun (if you can) and you also want to make sure your staff are safe and well and don't become sick or get injured as a result of working for you.
Your duty of care as an employer means that – quite rightly – your employees’ welfare is down to you. You’re obliged to do everything necessary to ensure their working environment is safe and any equipment you’ve supplied them with is fit for purpose.
Despite your best efforts, however, things can sometimes go wrong. What happens if an employee is injured or becomes ill and blames you? And worse, then sues you for damages?
As always, there’s an insurance policy that covers it. It’s called employers’ liability insurance and it’s a legal requirement for most businesses in the UK.
Who needs employers’ liability insurance?
Any company with one or more employees. The only exemptions are:
What does employers’ liability insurance pay for?
If a claim is made against you and you need to defend yourself (which you will), the insurer appoints and pays for legal expertise to fight your corner. The insurer also pays any compensation due to your employee as a result of a claim.
Who says I need employers’ liability insurance?
The Health and Safety Executive enforces the law on employers' liability. They could fine you up to £2,500 for any day you're without the necessary cover and £1,000 for not displaying the appropriate certificate.
How much cover do I need?
The minimum level of cover is £5m, but you’ll find most insurers only offer £10m. That sounds a lot, but it doesn’t mean it’s expensive. Annual premiums start from around £30-£40.
It’s usually quick and easy to sort out too, so don’t take any chances. I advise talking to a specialist broker to help point you in the right direction.
Nick Green, PolicyBee professional insurance brokers
I prefer the straight-talking approach – to life and business. But working in the recruitment sector means I know a lot about the smoke and mirrors and doublespeak agents use. Here are a few statements I’ve heard many times over the years – and an explanation of what they really mean.
“We’ll find the best candidates in the market place”
I’ll send you the CVs I have on file.
“We’ll network extensively to find you the right person for the role”
I’ll do a database search, post the job description online, send a tweet and write a wall post on Facebook.
“We charge 15% of total remuneration as a fee”
Kerrching – I’ll make £3,500 from this.
“There’s no negotiation on the fee – we add so much value, it’s justified”
I can’t believe people are still paying me to post jobs on social media websites when they could be doing it themselves for free. And I’m earning a £3,500 fee from this.
“We offer world-class service and want to help grow your business”
I’ll treat you like a god because there’s £3,500 fee in this for me and growing your business means more employees so I get richer too. It’s a win-win.
“I think you are making a big mistake not taking my candidate”
Bugger – I promised the missus a new car and now I’m not going to earn a bonus
Darren Leighfield, Director at EtcEtc Ltd
Venture capitalists deciding whether to invest in early-stage businesses will tell you that there are three things that they look for: people, people and people. It’s a slightly trite saying, but my experience says there’s wisdom in this approach.
I’ve recently joined the board of a financial services company that has gone from start-up to a multi-billion pound valuation in the lifetime of its founders. In fact, it’s the only FTSE 100 company to achieve this entirely by organic growth. It’s an amazing story and there are lots of lessons it could teach. A major part of the success has been down to one of the key early employees working alongside the founders.
In a similar way, when I started my own company, Actinic, we went from start-up to full listing on the London Stock Exchange in less than five years. The first recruit started working for us while the business was still in my house and was absolutely critical. He later became a director and has now gone on to be highly successful at other companies.
And again, Actinic’s biggest customer success story started out in a front room and grew to sales of £23m in a handful of years. Sure enough, their first employee went on to become the operations director and was a major driving force for the business during its development.
When you are starting a company, you have limited resources and husbanding them carefully is critical. It may seem difficult to be choosy when you are recruiting your first one or two staff, but it’s an important discipline. In fact, it’s up there with choosing the right business partner. If you get it right, it can be the first step on the road to huge success. If you get it wrong – it could be the end. Put more effort into your early recruitment than on any other issue. Believe me, the venture capitalists have got it right.
Chris Barling is CEO of ecommerce software supplier Actinic
Company bosses often set a key corporate objective to ensure that they gain a good listing in the league tables of those organisations judged to be the best places to work.
Those who organise the lists helpfully define the criteria for success, so aspiring companies can implement the best practices of the best companies and then persuade their people to affirm that they are indeed happy and are treated well.
As an entrepreneur, I often meet highly motivated people working in small teams. In larger organisations, particularly the public sector, the picture is not nearly so rosy. Even those who have escaped the current round of cuts can later feel guilty and de-motivated despite working in a relatively stable environment.
The best example I know of a company that knows how to recruit, motivate and reward their staff is not a high-powered corporate entity, but a social enterprise: The FRC Group.
Based in the north west, they have a number of operations, including Bulky Bob’s, a van-based collection and delivery service. They will pick up your old sofa, washing machine or other awkward item, re-cycle or repair them, and then resell to low-income families or anyone looking for a bargain.
They are a regular business, providing a valuable service for a tidy profit. What makes them a social enterprise, is that as well as the focus on recycling, most of the people who work there are long-term unemployed, ex-offenders, or otherwise challenged.
You know you are visiting somewhere special as soon as you walk through the door to see a personal welcome displayed at reception. This may seem obvious, but you would be surprised how few companies bother with this simple courtesy.
Shaun Doran, chief executive of The FRC Group explained to me that this not only makes visitors feel welcome, but also it spikes the curiosity of the staff, who are encouraged to engage with visitors as much as possible.
Rather than a standard name badge, the visitor chooses their own name badge, based on the core values of The FRC Group: bravery, creativity, passion and professionalism, another good conversation-opener.
The company’s interview process is well thought-out and focuses on the design of the job itself, its delivery criteria and metrics for measuring success. These are then reviewed by an external organisation, The Reward Group, to determine the appropriate financial rewards for good performance.
Each potential new employee then goes through a “values day” to see where they would best fit in. They are then given the opportunity to convince the interviewers that they are ready and willing to give the job their very best shot.
The induction process is very thorough and their subsequent employment is based on recognition and reward. Their photograph is displayed in a public area with ten interesting facts about the new joiner, and their step-by-step progress constantly monitored and again displayed publicly, with regular praise for a good job done.
But the best confidence-builder is their staff knowing that they have a specific “buddy”, who on their own first day was equally scared and confused, so is always available to put a hand around their shoulder and show them the ropes.
This is just a tiny glimpse into of the well-considered and highly effective methods the FRC Group use to make their company a great place to work. They would be delighted to welcome you to their place to explain how to recruit well and increase the self-esteem of your people.
If you do, you might even make it into the Financial Times’ own list of Best Places to Work one day.
Originally published in The Financial Times. Copyright ©Mike Southon 2011. All Rights Reserved. Not to be reproduced without permission in writing. Mike Southon is the co-author of The Beermat Entrepreneur and a business speaker.
What is your experience of working with recruitment consultants? Do you use them? Many businesses do, that’s why recruitment is such a lucrative market.
In the year-ending March 2009, the value of the permanent recruitment market in the UK stood at £2.61bn and the number of permanent placements made was 582,803.
What will happen next? Well, the times they are a changing.
According to the National Statistics office, 2.45m were unemployed for the three months up to September 2010. Many were claiming employment benefits and as such the job centre has become a hive of actively available job seekers.
Did you know that recruitment agencies advertise your job in the job centre and sell candidates to businesses for thousands of pounds?
We’re now witnessing an explosion in online social media. Forward-thinking recruitment consultants realised you can search someone’s job title through, say, Facebook, to generate candidates or start a discussion on LinkedIn, which are nothing more than job adverts, you can even tweet your latest job vacancy on Twitter.
So what does this mean? Well, recruitment agencies advertise your job using social media sites and sell you the candidate for thousands of pounds.
What are the alternatives? You could approach the leading job boards directly. Do you NEED a recruitment agency? Well, in many cases NO. Of course, recruitment agencies will tell you that’s not the case. A recruitment agent may save you time in searching and getting candidates before you, but you still have to interview them. Is that worth paying thousands of pounds for?
Darren Leighfield, Director at EtcEtc Ltd
Thanks to the global economy and the internet, the world is a smaller place. And now, hiring staff is insanely easy thanks to the rise of the remote-working freelancer.
For a start-up owner especially, the rise of the freelancer is absolute gold. Talent is available with a few clicks of a mouse, from the most difficult of tasks to the most trivial. Freelancing platforms such as Freelancer.co.uk give you an almost unlimited pool of ranked and reviewed suppliers willing to bid for your job.
The key benefits are cost-effectiveness and flexibility. As an entrepreneur I have hired freelancers for numerous tasks over the last few years, everything from research to SEO, web design to data entry. Using self-employed people has enabled me to match the business needs as and when required, often at lower cost and at short notice.
While this works for me, I know there are a lot of cynics, especially around the topic of hiring overseas at low cost. My response is simple: I want the best expertise I can afford. Sure, I have employed freelancers in China and India, but have often hired in the UK and US, too. You have to take a pragmatic approach.
Hiring freelance staff also makes sense where you have an ongoing, specialist job such as PR, SEO or accounting. There are independent experts in every field and outsourcing to one means you are freed up to concentrate on the core aspects of the business.
I know one new company, an email marketing provider, where the MD has a virtual, freelance team to run every aspect of the operation. It keeps his overheads low and makes him very nimble in a crowded marketplace.
The global economy is transforming the way we work. Could freelancers transform the way your start-up works?
Ben Dyer is an IT Donut expert and Director of product development at Actinic
Writing recruitment adverts needn’t be a chore and, if done well, it can transform your response, generate strong interest and attract good candidates.
Think first. Focus on what you’re trying to achieve – attract the right person for the requirements of the role. If you’re to do that, you must attract the attention of the target audience, tell them what they need to know and persuading them to reply. Make sure you have a clear idea of your target audience and how your advert will reach them.
If necessary – carry out some basic research. Maybe the salary you’re offering is a bit low – or too high. Before you can write your advert you also need to carefully consider the contribution the role needs to make to your business. Only then can you set out the skills, knowledge and experience you seek.
You must get the tone of your advert right. Formal language will work best for certain roles, while in others it might put candidates off. Even if you opt for a formal tone, remember – you’re communicating with human beings. Keep it friendly, almost as if you were having a conversation with the reader.
Good candidates won’t want to read the same dull, old lines they’ve read in a thousand and one other job adverts. Quickly they must be able to recognise (or not) their suitability for the role and the benefits this will bring to them.
Try and be creative. I admit it’s easier said than done. Try and say something that other adverts don’t. Perhaps you’re offering a brand new role or unique opportunity in a new market. Find a unique selling point for the role and do a good job of selling your business to readers.
Get the structure of your advertisement right. There’s an accepted structure; one that readers know, recognise, trust and expect. You include something about your business; something about the job; something about the person you’re looking for; and something about the benefits. You’ve also got to tell people how you want them to respond (ie by letter or email?) and what the deadline is.
Also make sure you include an attention-grabbing title. Throughout your copy, avoid clichés, business speak and jargon. Keep the language simple and to the point. When finished, use your spell check, because any errors will reflect badly on your business. Get someone else to read through the copy, just to make sure there are no mistakes and that all key information is included. Good luck.
Darren Leighfield, Director at EtcEtc Ltd
There’s nothing like the subject of maternity and paternity leave to get people hot under the collar. And so the news that the government is proposing a more flexible system that will encourage men and women to share parental leave has had mixed reactions in the business community.
The new approach will come into effect in 2015 and could include new provisions for parents to take time off in several short blocks.
“We support moves to make parental leave more flexible,” says Katja Hall, CBI director for employment policy — or ‘the voice of reason’, as I call her. “This will help families better balance their work and home life.” But she adds, “Any changes will need to be simple to administer and must allow firms to plan ahead to cover staff absences.”
Absolutely. No-one wants to hamstring businesses.
So what are the arguments against this new flexibility? Some business groups are saying that shorter periods of leave will be too difficult to manage. They say it’s already hard enough for small firms in particular to find cover for employees on parental leave. Some even warn that the proposals could see some small firms going out of business.
OK, it can be challenging for small firms to cover staff on leave. But it’s not impossible. Who are these totally irreplaceable people? And I really don’t buy the idea that parental leave could bring an otherwise healthy small business to its knees.
Mind you, this is the constructive criticism. The more outlandish comments online include rants about “the scroungers who see baby breeding as a way of life” and the suggestion that we “look at this question again when men start giving birth”.
Let’s stick to the facts, people. Lots of couples decide to have kids. Often both of them work. Babies need looking after. People need to work. How individual families approach the division of labour — both bread-winning and domestic duties — should be entirely up to them.
I believe that making parental leave arrangements more flexible can only be good for businesses. By spreading the leave between two parents, the absence of one individual employee is likely to be shorter. And taking that leave in shorter blocks could make it easier for businesses to manage without that employee — knowing they won’t be gone for long.
Of course it all depends how it is administered and managed. Small businesses don’t need any more red tape, that’s for sure. And while these new parental rights are to be welcomed, businesses have rights, too — the right to be kept fully informed with enough notice to make their own arrangements.
The Department for Business is to launch a consultation with businesses on this issue soon. Perhaps if the nay-sayers were to look at the proposals more constructively, instead of offering their usual knee-jerk reaction, we could develop an enlightened approach to parental leave that is good for families and good for businesses.
Paternity leave reform plans “ignore business needs”
Find out how to deal with parental leave on the Law Donut
Previous articles on parental leave
Dec 2010: Small firms applaud EU rejection of maternity pay extension
September 2010: Maternity leave extension too costly for small firms, warns BCC
March 2010: Less than a fifth of workers would take extended paternity leave
Research published recently by office-space provider Regus suggests the number of UK businesses who would take on working mums if they were recruiting has fallen significantly in the past year.
More than 1,000 UK businesses were surveyed and only 26 per cent said they would hire a woman with children, compared with 38 per cent last year. According to Regus: “With 43 per cent of firms saying they plan to increase employee numbers this year [itself quite a remarkable statistic], the proportion intending to recruit working mums is worryingly low.”
Sadly, when asked for key reasons, the same tired, old excuses (not reasons) reared their ugly heads. Some 38% fear “working mothers may show less commitment and flexibility than other employees”; while “31% believe working mums will leave to have another child”; and “17% are worried that women who return to the workplace will have out-of-date skills”.
Why are so many UK employers still stuck in the 1970s with their thinking when it comes to women with children? I’d wager that many of respondents were male – whadya reckon? And behind most successful businessmen, usually there’s a dutiful wife tucked away in the suburban background, who’s quietly looked after the kids and home for years.
Women seemed damned if they do and damned if they don’t. Most working mums I’ve worked with over the years could give many of their colleagues lessons in commitment. Trying to balance a career with childcare is no small challenge. Most families these days can only get by on two incomes, so many women have no choice but to return to work after having children – they do so out of necessity, not choice.
And while many women are allowed to work fewer days after having children (employers who facilitate such flexible arrangements take a bow), most working mums feel under added scrutiny and immense pressure to achieve the same results. They could give lessons in working hard, too. Many working mums try to cram as much work into their reduced working week as they did previously, which can eventually takes its toll.
The use of the word “flexibility” by respondents is interesting. This, of course, usually means willingness to habitually work for no pay. Surely by now we all know it’s about working smarter, not longer? And if your business really has to rely on employees’ willingness to work for free, you’ve really got problems. As long as people work the hours for which they are paid, employers can’t really complain.
On a more positive note, again according to Regus, 67 per cent or those surveyed said employers who ignored the potential contribution returning mothers can make are “missing out on a significant and valuable part of the employment pool”.
More than half (51%) regard working mums as “offering skills that are difficult to find in the current market”; and (revealingly) 45% value returning mothers because “they offer experience and skills without demanding top salaries”. (The implication being that some employers believe these women are just glad to have a job, so they won’t ask for pay parity with male colleagues.)
Generalising is a foolish and dangerous act. It’s certainly not my personal experience, but I’m sure there are women who show less commitment and don’t work as hard after they return to work after having children. In many ways, it’s a natural consequence. But as with any other employee, if there are problems with a working mum’s punctuality, attendance, productivity or quality, then your business should have processes and mechanisms to resolve them.
Some women will soon leave again – either temporarily or permanently – to have more children, and this often creates headaches for business owners and managers. But not taking on women with children or women of a certain age for fear they will soon have children isn’t the answer.
It seems some employers still have a lot to learn when it comes to the two-way streets that are commitment and flexibility.
We’ve all heard the news that times are tough for graduates, suffering from cut-backs in jobs and graduate schemes due to the ever-present state of the economy. While bad for ex-students, this is potentially good news for employers as there is a massive pool of keen and well-educated young people, ready to bite your arm off for a job, or even just work experience.
In some respects, these young people are blank canvases that can be moulded to fit your way of working. And, with more degree courses than ever before including a work-placement, plus the majority of students having to supplement their income with a part-time job, it’s likely that employment isn’t a completely alien concept.
If your business is in the fledgling stages, taking on experienced members of staff might be a risky expense you can’t afford. What graduates lack in experience, they make up for in brains, quick-thinking and a fresh attitude. The majority are eager to learn and will cost a lot less than somebody that has earned their stripes following many years on the career ladder. If it’s just a placement you’re offering, potentially, graduates won’t cost a penny – although I have to say, I am not particularly supportive of the current trend for abusing the situation and getting graduates to work for long periods, for nothing.
There is funding available. In the North East, for example, Graduates for Business, offers £70 a week towards the salary of a graduate for the first 15 weeks of their employment. Specifically aimed at smaller businesses, qualifying SMEs must have less than 250 employees and be able to pay new graduates a minimum of £14,000 a year. For information about graduate funding in your area, visit www.businesslink.gov.uk.
For a short-term commitment, a placement can provide a mutually beneficial exchange between employers and graduates – particularly in the summer holidays when those that are still studying have a lot of spare time on their hands. Depending on the length of the placement, this doesn’t necessarily have to be paid – especially if it’s over the summer break – however be realistic, if you take someone on for six months and don’t pay them a bean, then that’s a little unfair!
Rate my placement is a website for undergraduates looking for work experience and employers offering internships – like a job dating agency. Students will ‘rate your placement’ so it’s important that if you get involved, you provide good levels of training. Placements can be anything from a few months to over a year.
Giving these young people a chance could be good for your business and will help dent the massive levels of graduate unemployment. If all goes well, you never know, you might find just the right person to take your company on to the next level.
Anita Brook, founder of Chartered Accountancy firm, Accounts Assist
I love my job and what I do and as a result I spend lots of my life seeing and hearing things and then being unable to stop myself relating them to being a good leader and what makes organisations work. I guess if I was a musician I’d always have songs in my head!
A few days ago we were doing a long journey in the car and we put story CDs on in the car for our young sons to listen to - and so, for the first time in ages, I heard Aesop’s Fables. Initially I wasn’t really tuned in and then I heard this one and BANG my mind was back in work mode again:
The Belly and the Members Fable - An Aesop’s Fable
One fine day it occurred to the Members of the Body that they were doing all the work and the Belly was having all the food. So they held a meeting, and after a long discussion, decided to strike work till the Belly consented to take its proper share of the work. So for a day or two, the Hands refused to take the food, the Mouth refused to receive it, and the Teeth had no work to do. But after a day or two the Members began to find that they themselves were not in a very active condition: the Hands could hardly move, and the Mouth was all parched and dry, while the Legs were unable to support the rest. So thus they found that even the Belly in its dull quiet way was doing necessary work for the Body, and that all must work together or the Body will go to pieces.
As I listened, it occurred to me that we so often feel that we are the ones who are doing all the work, whether it be at work or at home – and we forget that there are other people in the team who are doing their bit too, but in a quiet, often overlooked way.
I regularly facilitate in situations where someone is convinced that the other departments or individuals aren’t pulling their weight – and I get them to understand and/or work in each other’s departments and also encourage them to make sure their own house is in order before they start casting around to give criticism. These approaches get good results, but I think I’m going to add this fable into my toolkit as it underlines the point very succinctly and is a great model for good organisational design. I probably need to pin it on the fridge at home too!
Emma Warren, Portfolio Directors
This post originally appeared on Emma Warren's blog
Nasty Nick Griffin’s much-publicised appearance on Question Time raised a lot of questions, namely about democracy and freedom of speech, and about how much freedom is too much when your views just happen to be fascist.
Pay attention employers, because these uncomfortable questions may be closer to home than you think.
The media has started its own debate over the BBC’s invitation to Griffin to join other, mainstream politicians on its flagship current affairs programme; The Guardian claims the BNP is losing the support of even its own loyalists over Griffin’s performance, while The Telegraph insists the programme has given the party a platform from which to ensnare new supporters.
Either way, the BNP has upset and enraged a lot of people in the last few days alone, with its anti-almost-everybody viewpoints. Democracy is democracy, and you can’t ignore that more than a handful of people are putting their crosses in the BNP box, but it is a challenge for every one of us to decide how to deal with this.
Look a little deeper and there are parallels here with the workplace. How far should you allow your employees to discuss their religious, social or political views in the workplace, if there is a risk that they could seriously upset other people with them?
Luckily, as a business owner, there is a more clearly defined line for you to draw, partly because your employees have not been elected or recruited on their personal policies, although healthy debate can benefit your business in many ways.
While your staff obviously have a human right to manifest their beliefs and express their opinions, you must keep a beady eye out to ensure that what they express does not discriminate against or undermine other employees. It may be unlikely that you have a BNP activist in your midst, but any viewpoint that undermines someone based on their gender, age, race or religion, or simply makes them feel uncomfortable, can have serious consequences.
Aside from a dent in your team’s morale, constant controversial comments or an over-zealous employee trying to convert people to their religion or cause can lead to staff absence or legal claims of discrimination or harassment, both of which can be expensive and damaging.
Speaking to Acas equality specialist, Steve Williams, recently, I found out that employers can protect their business from these perils by including some pointers in their HR policy, and by having a quiet word with anyone that breaches them.
“Emphasise that discussion is welcome but that it must not be used to oppress or discriminate against other staff,” he adds. “Spell it out — for example, it is acceptable for an employee to mention that they go to church or campaign for the Green Party, but if they start pressurising other people, that isn’t.”
On the bright side, Williams told me that most employees have an “innate sense” of where the line should be drawn with regard to other people’s feelings, and would soon apologise if they realised they had overstepped it. If we are to take his word for it, there’s a good chance you will never be faced with this complex problem. Nevertheless, in the face of an increasingly re-politicised population, you should be well-prepared.
The two most common complaints in business are that no one asked me and no one told me. While, in my experience, it’s impossible to ever fully eliminate these complaints, making a concerted effort at addressing them can lead to a big boost in team morale.
As a manager, I feel that if I don’t tell people what’s going on, I can’t complain if they fill in the gaps with negatives. And if they don’t feel that their input is taken seriously, they will become de-motivated and probably work less hard, as well as putting up with things that frankly, they should be screaming about.
In fact, listening is the key to continuous improvement. I do try to practice what I preach and I interview all staff, including those in junior roles, on a regular basis. It doesn’t take all that long, it’s amazing what you find out, and the very act of listening leads to a big improvement in morale.
Another angle that we have tried is to hold a series of workshop sessions with all staff whenever we review our strategy. These enable us to get useful input on the broad thrust of the strategy, and identify many of the potential pitfalls. It also means that we communicate and get buy in as we go along. By the time the strategy is completed, everybody is on board and starting to act on it. This is hugely better than a brilliant strategy done by outside consultants but that sits beautifully documented but largely untouched on the shelf. With that sort of strategy, you wonder a year later why the business isn’t really following it, and why it faces resistance at every turn. The lesson is that it’s important to explain where you are going to everybody even when you are a small company.
In most businesses, money is not a great motivator, but can certainly be a great de-motivator. So it’s important to try to be consistent in how you reward people, and also to explain pay policies so that there is a degree of buy in. Sometimes, it may be better to reward with bonuses rather than pay rises, as rises institutionalize pay differentials in ways that may become unfair over time, They can’t easily be unpicked and when discovered will destroy morale.
Motivation is a funny thing, and is pretty hard to achieve. I hope that some of the ideas here will stimulate your further thoughts.
So that’s it then, Manchester Brit Pop icons Oasis have finally called it a day, following an alleged violent “altercation” back stage between singer Liam and guitarist Noel, only moments before they were due to play at a show in Paris recently.
Noel has said he can no longer work another day with Liam (AKA “our kid”) and as a result the rest of the band’s sell-out tour was cancelled, leaving fans with tickets for shows at V and elsewhere none too happy.

Whether Oasis will record or play together again is anyone’s guess, but the fracas between the brothers Gallagher (and their numerous, widely reported previous bust-ups) highlights the dangers of working with your “nearest and dearest”. This is an important consideration for many new and existing small businesses, of course, where enterprises are often jointly formed by married couples, siblings, parents and children, work colleagues or just good friends.
Having worked for quite a few husband-and-wife management teams, I’ve seen both sides of the coin at close quarters. I’ve experienced how it can work perfectly well, where couples are able to successfully leave “domestic stuff” at home once the world of business has been entered. Being able to share responsibility and workload with someone close to you can be a good thing. It can certainly make running a business a less lonely pursuit.
Family businesses or those run by friends can and do succeed. According to the Federation of Small Businesses, about 65 per cent of the UK’s 4.6m small firms are family-run enterprises. They generate about 30 per cent of UK GDP and employ some 3m people. Interestingly, about 56 per cent of family businesses are sole traders with no employees. By the way, on the Start Up Donut, you’ll find an excellent Q&A interview with a legal expert about drawing up contracts with family members who invest in your business.
However much of a challenge, if your family-run business is to succeed, you also must be adept at not taking “work stuff” home, of course. You’ve got to be able to separate the domestic and business spheres, while (in the case of spouses) perhaps accept that the distribution of power in the workplace might need to be wholly different to the home, where the other person might indeed “wear the trousers”.
Not everyone is up to the challenge and the dream of running a successful business with a spouse, relation or mate can quickly go wrong, however much you believed you could trust and rely on them. The pressure of work and money often brings out the worst in people.
I also recall being able to judge how “good” a night or weekend one young husband and wife management team had had at home by their relations in the workplace, which ranged from sickeningly lovey-dovey to barely concealed hostility – both of which often left others around them feeling very uncomfortable. If, as suspected, they’d had a spectacular row at home, then often the wife would be too “unwell” to come into work, but make a Lazarus-like recovery to full health the next day, presumably after they’d kissed and made up.
Often (well-founded) resentment can also be felt by employees, especially when a family member is given preferential treatment (eg extra time off) or responsibility way out of line with their skills, knowledge and ability.
Financial rewards and issues around commitment to the business can also quickly and permanently sour relations, which is why it’s wise to establish expectations (and document them, especially when it comes to financial investment) before starting a business with your spouse, family member or friend, then everyone at least knows where they stand and what’s expected.
Open and honest communication is a crucial, too. If one of the parties isn’t pulling their weight, for example, not feeling able to tell them will lead to severe problems sooner or later. It will probably even spell the end for the business and the relationship – something else I’ve witnessed close up and personal as an employee in family-run businesses.
As the old saying goes, better to build a friendship on business rather than a business on friendship. I’m sure Noel would agree.
I dread appraisals. I sit through every one clenched and sweating, convinced I’ve cost the company gazillions in lost business and waiting for my boss to tell me to clear my desk and get out. I expect I have a face like a frightened deer. I also expect my boss thinks I have some sort of nervous disorder (I probably do).
In fact, I usually leave the room feeling fairly chipper. I’m lucky enough to work for a company that uses appraisals to give a fair review, set realistic objectives and listen to what I have to say about the business. Which is as it should be, right?
It seems I’m one of the lucky ones. An Investors in People survey revealed this week that almost one in three (29%) UK employees believe appraisals are a waste of time, and just under a quarter (23%) think their boss sees an appraisal as nothing more than a bureaucratic exercise.
This is a shame, because no matter how much I dread my appraisal I appreciate its value. But it gets worse. The research implies that the UK’s small businesses don’t particularly care about appraisals, with only slightly more than half (54%) even bothering to offer them to staff. This compares with four in five (81%) bigger businesses.
It’s easy to take figures like these and use them to create a picture of an army of hard-nosed small business owners shouting “Stop whingeing and get on with it!” every time an employee has the cheek to express a smidgeon of dissatisfaction. But I don’t believe this for a second. In fact, I’m willing to bet that most of the people who think their appraisal is a waste of time work for bigger businesses, not smaller ones.
The reason I think this is something the big boss at our company, BHP, said to me this week. I was picking his brains for an article on staff retention and he suddenly leant forward, fixed me with a rueful gaze and declared, “The problem is, Simon, that as soon as you get to ten employees you stop having personal relationships with them. You have to introduce systems.”
He’s right. As businesses grow, the gap between the boss and the people at the other end of the chain also grows until, eventually, they don’t know each other at all, and everybody matters just a little bit less. So you need appraisals, to keep tabs on everyone – and, sometimes, just to give the impression that you care. At this point they can become a waste of time.
In a smaller business, the boss has more far more opportunity to find out what makes their staff tick, what they want to achieve, how they’re getting on with the job. Bosses who take the time to get to know their staff may not feel the need to conduct an appraisal every year or every quarter; they’re already doing it, every day. This doesn’t mean they shouldn’t conduct formal appraisals; but it does mean that when they do their appraisals are far more likely to have value, simply because they care.