It’s free business advice – but is it reliable?

It’s free business advice – but is it reliable?

July 14, 2011 by Alan Gleeson

While running a small business is highly rewarding, it’s not easy. Yet more of us are being enticed into starting a business, encouraged by an increasingly supportive government that promotes entrepreneurship at every opportunity. This is good news. As entrepreneurs innovate, we as consumers benefit as they produce products and services that better meet our needs. Governments benefit through a greater tax take and lower social welfare costs. Everyone’s a winner.

Key challenge

However, a key challenge for most entrepreneurs is dealing with the numerous issues they must address – when all most want to do is sell. Their knowledge base must not only span their sector, it must also cover a wealth of functional issues ranging from marketing and HR to cashflow management and taxation, etc.

While bigger companies will typically have access to this knowledge in-house, smaller businesses don’t. Instead, for help they turn to their network as well as search engines, blogs, websites and business forums. 

Social media

One of the benefits of the growth of social media is information about pretty much any subject is available for free on the internet, making it much easier to access than previously. The quality of information is significant and search costs are low, resulting in unfettered access to solutions to your every business problem.

But all is not as straightforward as it might seem. Information gleaned from these sources is not without its drawbacks, not least, for the most part – you don’t know who you are getting the knowledge from.

Some of the following issues also apply:

  • How can you assess the veracity of the information?
  • How do you ensure the impartiality of the content?
  • How do you take general advice and apply it to your own circumstances?
  • What if you rely on information and then act on it to your detriment?

Factual accuracy and substantiation

Firstly, taking information at ‘face value’ is rarely a good thing. Consider each bit of advice as a mere data point as you seek to gather information to make a decision. You should also seek out articles supported by facts with clear attribution to source data where you can substantiate claims.

Secondly, it is important to assess the nature of your inquiry, relative to the risks associated with the decision to be made. Information gleaned from a search engine or website is no substitute for paid-for advice when dealing with legal or taxation matters, for instance. While we have all become accustomed to using search engines for information searches, we must not lose sight of the fact that nurturing a wide network of contacts from which you can request advice is a better use of your time than surfing the net for solutions to more complex issues.

It is also worth considering the context of the information. Is it on a commercial site where the author has a commercial agenda or is it on an informational site such as Wikipedia, where the content is curated by a number of contributors? Articles written on branded websites, with full author accreditation (and clear domain expertise), trump anonymous postings on poor-quality websites every time. However, you must remember that, unlike professional advice, there is generally no come back if you suffer damages as a result of acting on erroneous information.

Incomplete information

As an entrepreneur you also must constantly weigh up the costs of a decision and need to become comfortable dealing with incomplete information. As venture capitalist Mark Suster eloquently puts it:

“You are constantly faced with decisions and there is always incomplete information. This paralyzes most people. Not you. Entrepreneurs make fast decisions and move forward knowing that at best 70% of their decisions are going to be right. They move the ball forward every day. They are quick to spot their mistakes and correct. Good entrepreneurs can admit when their course of action was wrong and learn from it. Good entrepreneurs are wrong often. If you’re not, then you’re not trying hard enough. Good entrepreneurs have a penchant for doing vs. over-analyzing. (Obviously don’t read this as zero analysis).”

Finally, it is worth remembering that general information is subject to cognitive biases, and accredited sources used in support of the arguments may be from wildly different contexts from the one in which you are attempting to apply your learnings.

Alan Gleeson is general manager of Palo Alto Software Ltd, creators of Business Plan Pro®. He holds an MBA from Oxford University and an MSc from University College, Cork, Ireland. 

Comments

Good advice. I think of the internet as a series of lily pads in a big pond of knowledge - one piece of information often bounces onto another, and onto another, and onto another; you can often get to a point where enough different sources have more or less corroborated each other; and for me, that usually has to be the 'good enough to work with' I'm looking for!

That's the trade off - the internet gives us access to tons more information than ever before, but you always have to bear in mind that it may actually be wrong! Ultimately, you should see a lot of this information as the starting point in getting knowledge.

Add a comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <p>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Links to specified hosts will have a rel="nofollow" added to them.

When you click 'Register' to create a new account, you accept our terms of service and privacy policy